Army APFT taking it too often, what should I do?

FM's are guidelines, not black and white inked in rules. Your Commander can implement an overweight or PT Failure special needs program as they see fit. I was in a unit that you did special needs PT after duty hours and on Saturday if you had anyone that was over tape or a PT Failure. For over three years I did PT Ten times a week, organized PT in the morning, special needs at night and once on Saturday as I always had at least one of either category. That be the breaks. Go complain all you want and wave that FM around because your jousting at windmills. Just stay with the program and get off the overweight and keep yourself off of it and in your case I think staying off of it would be a heck of an incentive as opposed to the program they have in place.